Carey, 55, received the Icon Award at this year's presentation, where she was honored with performances by Tori Kelly and ...

The Queen of Christmas gave fans another viral reaction to use online as she gave side-eye during a tribute performance.

“Y’all look at Mariah’s reaction while Muni Long was singing a tribute to her. I am hollering,” one user wrote with crying emojis, inferring that Carey was specifically reacting to the “We Belong ...

But what might end up being the biggest and longest-lasting headline from the night – or at least, a GIF that will live on for the ages – Carey was shown on camera offering a deadpan head-turn ...

Fans online instantly perceived her facial expression to be a sign of disapproval. "New Mariah Carey MEME!" one X user ...